The Middle Ages That Never Were

There seems to be a fixed idea that, at least until very recently, most fantasy has been set in a mediaeval-type setting. This is almost an article of faith to many people, in the face of all evidence, and shows that they have very little understanding of what mediaeval1 really means.

Some fantasy authors have certainly based their settings on mediaeval Europe, from William Morris to George R. R. Martin. However, this is only one of many models that traditional fantasy authors have used — though it’s undeniable that most have been centred on Europe or the Middle East.

Tolkien is often cited as an author who uses a mediaeval model, but in fact there’s very little mediaeval, as properly understood, in Lord of the Rings. The Shire is an idealised version of 19th century England without guns; Rohan is early Anglo-Saxon; the Dwarves are ancient Norse; Gondor has a distinctly Babylonian feel, although I suspect Tolkien was going for Solomon’s Israel; and some of the other cultures, such as Lothlorien, have no obvious real-world model.

Similarly, most of the pulp fantasy of the 30s and 40s, such as the Conan stories, tend to be set in a mashed-up imagining of the classical world and the pre-classical Middle East. Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser’s environment, on the other hand, has a lot in common with Renaissance Mediterranean culture. In general, while some mediaeval influence was there, it was only one type of setting among many.

What Were the Middle Ages?

The problem seems to be the common assumption that any pre-gunpowder period is mediaeval. In fact, the term only refers to a few hundred years (for part of which gunpowder actually was in use) on one of the world’s smallest continents.

To give a sense of perspective — besides Europe, civilisation has existed (before modern colonisation) in Asia, Africa, North America and South America2. The earliest known civilisation (i.e. people living in a city) was over 11,000 years ago, in the town later known as Jericho.

In reality, the Middle Ages (also known as the mediaeval period) didn’t exist at all. It was a sneering term coined in the Renaissance to dismiss western Europe between the fall of the classical world (good) and the birth of the new age (nearly as good). In the same way, the sometimes-exquisite art and architecture of the period was described as Gothic, implying it was the work of the barbarians who’d destroyed the Roman Empire.

The period the Renaissance scholars thus consigned to the scrapheap actually covers many different cultures, over both its timespan and its geographical distribution, although there are certain generalisations that can be made.

There isn’t even any clear agreement as to when it started or finished. To some extent, of course, all historical periods are just convenient places for historians to begin and end their books. Some periods have more obvious bookmarks, but it’s rare to have such a significant change that people living at the time would notice it.

My own view, with all possible disclaimers in place, is that the Middle Ages (to the extent that they existed at all) started in 732 AD3 and finished in 1453. On a Tuesday. At teatime.

When and How Did the Middle Ages Begin?

Everyone knows that the Roman Empire fell in the 5th century. Except that it didn’t. The Roman Empire had been changing and evolving throughout its lifetime, most obviously after the reforms of Diocletian in the late 3rd century. By the 5th century, it consisted mainly of barbarian warlords controlling their own territories and paying nominal fealty to the Emperor. This would have unrecognisable to Augustus, five hundred years earlier.

When the last western Emperor was deposed in 476, these warlords and their peoples just carried on the same way. The only difference was that they paid even more nominal fealty to the eastern Emperor in Constantinople, where the Roman Empire carried on until the 15th century.

For the most part, the barbarian warlords were proud of being part of the Empire. They fought the legions internally, as when the Emperor Honorius double-crossed the Visigoths and they besieged Rome, but they’d no wish to tear it down. Well, except for the Huns, but they were a rival empire, not a ravening horde.

Nothing substantially changed. Civilisation and culture had been declining through the later part of the imperium, most notably in the decline of cities and the rise of serfdom, and continued to do so. In fact, it wouldn’t have been obvious at the time that the Roman Empire was gone for good. It was just a pause.

In this situation, western Europe largely marked time and didn’t really move on to anything new till the Frankish leader Charles Martel smashed the Moors at the Battle of Tours in 732.

There are two reasons why this was crucial. For one thing, although Charles was never actually king of the Franks, his son was crowned and his grandson became Charles the Great — Charlemagne. By the time the Carolingian dynasty had played out, only a few generations later, the map of Europe had changed beyond recognition, the first signs of our modern nations were stirring, and the concept of empire had been updated.

The second reason was the reason why Charles Martel had won the battle. This was a radical new type of fighting-man he’d copied from the Byzantine Empire, called the knight.

Aristocrats in older civilisations are sometimes described as knights, but this is retrospective. The knight as we know him first arose in Persia, following the introduction of stirrups, which made heavy cavalry possible for the first time. Unfortunately, the equipment and, in particular, the great war-horses were expensive to keep up.

The Persians solved the problem by imposing crippling taxes on the cities, with the result that, when the Arabs invaded, the cities opened their gates and went over to a more reasonable enemy. The Byzantines, learning from this, came up with a new idea: to give each knight a parcel of land and let him pay his own way. It was this concept Charles adopted, and so the feudal system was born.

The feudal system was, if anything was, the central institution of the Middle Ages, and any fantasy setting that doesn’t have it can’t be described as mediaeval. In reality, it was two separate but complementary systems. One was a contract the king made with his nobles and knights, whereby he granted them land and they undertook to fight for him when called on. In fact, many knights were more interested in running their estates, and it became increasingly common, as the period wore on, for knights to pay money in lieu of service, which the king would use to hire mercenaries.

The other, which had existed since the later Roman period, was manorial serfdom. Serfs were distinct from slaves in that, though they weren’t free to leave or refuse to work, they belonged to a manor, not to a person.

They had rights, too, although that varied considerably from kingdom to kingdom. English serfs in general had the strongest rights. The feudal system wasn’t used in England until after 1066, and many of the people’s ancestral rights were restored a few decades later.

Serfs in other kingdoms were usually a lot worse off, but the lord of the manor didn’t legally have any power of life or death over them. Of course, that assumed that they’d be held to account if they broke the law — which sometimes happened.

When and How Did the Middle Ages End?

And what about the end of the Middle Ages? 1453 was the year that Constantinople, the last remnant of the Roman Empire, fell to the Turks. The immediate significance was that many scholars and artists fled to the west, fuelling the already growing Renaissance in learning and the arts.

In fact, the Renaissance wasn’t a sudden development, and the Middle Ages weren’t quite as culturally bleak a period as they’re often painted, although certainly a low point. Knowledge had been seeping in for some time. Much of this had come from the Islamic world, at that time the most culturally advanced civilisation in the west. Art certainly took a huge step forward in the Renaissance, but it’s been suggested that the biggest academic change was that they started following Plato instead of Aristotle.

Besides the Renaissance, though, the mid-15th century marks a point where most of the characteristics of the Early Modern age were already becoming established. Gunpowder had come to stay and was making the transition from field guns to hand guns, rendering knights obsolete. Gutenberg was setting up his printing press in Mainz, and the voyages of discovery were well under way — the Portuguese were venturing down the African coast en route to India, leading the Spanish eventually to try another direction.

Social mobility was growing, too, as was religious dissent. Neither were anything like as absent from the Middle Ages as is often assumed, but both increased immensely after the Black Death.

The mediaeval Church was either divided or powerless for much of the period, and there’d been radical preachers from at least the 12th century whose arguments were essentially similar to Luther’s four hundred years later. By the 15th century, spurred by widespread distrust of a Church that had been able to do nothing about the Plague, dissenting movements led by Wycliffe, Ball, Huss and many others became bigger and better organised. Luther’s was simply the most successful of these.

In the same way, there had been towns and cities throughout the Middle Ages, and industries had flourished there. It wasn’t easy to escape from serfdom, except by going into the Church, but those who managed it had the chance of getting rich. After the Black Death, the feudal restraints became untenable, due to the shortage of manpower making labour a marketable commodity. The powers that be fought a long rearguard action against change, but it was becoming inevitable.

Know Your Middle Ages

The Middle Ages were a long and varied period — even without considering the great civilisations that flourished outside western Europe — and almost everything changed in their course. The armour worn by knights, for instance, developed from ring-mail sewn onto leather to the familiar suits of plate armour (which, contrary to popular belief, were not too heavy to manoeuvre in), driven by changing weapon technology.

At any given time, none of the typical mediaeval institutions were present everywhere, and some areas — Scandinavia, for instance — were barely affected till very late in the period.

So, if you want to create a fantasy setting “based on the mediaeval period”, by all means do so — you’ll be in good company. Decide what you actually mean by that, though, and do plenty of research on the specific country and era that interests you.

On the other hand, if all you want is for your hero to wield a sword or use a bow and arrow, you have an entire planet and eleven thousand years of civilisation to your model your world on. Why not have fun?

1 The original and most accurate spelling of the word is mediaeval, but medieval is now more common and acceptable. Seeing the word (as I all too often have) spelt midevil makes me want to stick my head in a bucket of water and scream. Please don’t make me do that.

2 Pre-colonial Australia can’t exactly be described as a civilisation, in the strict sense, though that doesn’t make its cultures any less rich and fascinating.

3 Yes, I use BC and AD, which have served perfectly well for the past 1500 years. Get over it.

Quest — A Fantasy-Writers.org Anthology

There have been a few moments in my writing life that have changed everything. One was a long walk I took the family dog on when I was fifteen, in the course of which I thought up and planned a story which proved to be the germ for much of what I’ve written since.

Another happened on the 31st January 2004, when I Googled “fantasy writing groups”, intending to search through what was out there to see if anything might be helpful. The first option I tried was a website called Fantasy-Writers.org. I joined, looked around and ignored the rest of the list.

More than twenty-one years later, I’m still part of FWO (as we like to call it), now as one of the site’s administrators. Virtually every story I’ve written since then has been through the FWO critiquing process, which has helped dozens get published — including a novel. I’ve learnt vast amounts about writing from the forum discussions, and from both giving and receiving critiques. And I’ve made a lot of good friends.

Eleven years ago, we published an anthology, Light of the Last Day, consisting of stories and poems by members. It turned out pretty well, but was extremely hard work — which is probably why it’s taken us till now to get to the follow-up.

This time, we decided to go for a theme. The concept of the Monomyth, or the Hero’s Journey, is a familiar one to many people. It was first proposed in 1949 by Joseph Campbell as a way of defining a common structure of stories, from ancient myths to contemporary media. He structured it as a hero on a journey involving a series of Jungian-style archetypes, which is at the same time a journey from childhood to adulthood.

Campbell’s Journey was a complex affair with seventeen stages, but more recently Christopher Vogler has proposed a simpler version, with only twelve stages. Essentially, the hero begins in their Ordinary World, goes through a series of challenges, dangers and opportunities to the quest’s fulfilment, and then returns with a real or virtual treasure as a reborn and transformed person.

Our plan was that each author should write a complete story relating to one specific stage of the Journey. Not as part of some overarching plot, but as a tapestry that, put together, would display every part of the Monomyth.

Although we toyed with the idea of twelve authors each claiming a specific stage, we decided to make it looser. We invited everyone to post a story on the site (either as part of our monthly challenge or more randomly) using any stage they liked. And then, as inevitably there were stages no-one had chosen, some authors submitted a second story, to help fill the gaps.

The upshot was that we ended up with twenty-two stories from seventeen authors, with every stage covered at least once. And then the fun began.

Each story underwent FWO’s usual process of peer critique — twice, for the first and second draft. Then, with all revisions complete, some of us volunteered to line-edit the stories, working on details such as grammar, punctuation and word choice. And, when both author and editor were happy, the stories were ready.

So what have we ended up with? These twenty-two stories are a mix of high fantasy, low fantasy, sword & sorcery, contemporary fantasy, and even a touch of science fiction and Afrofuturism. Not to mention one or two that defy classification. They might thrill you or make you think, they might make you laugh or cry. Fantasy covers it all.

FWO is a broad gathering of authors from many countries and many places along their writing journeys. Countries represented in this anthology include the USA, the UK, Australia, France, Germany, Malaysia, Egypt and Nigeria, and authors range from complete beginners to some who make their living from writing.

So the voices in the anthology might be idiosyncratic, and they use many different versions of the great Global English language — and that’s fine. Our variety is our strength. And, while we were prepared to find tactful ways of telling authors their stories weren’t quite up to scratch, it turned out that we didn’t need to. Which, I think, is a testament to the level of support we give each other in FWO.

Generally speaking, this anthology has been a communal effort, but in the end it takes one person to pull it all together. I’d like to thank B. R. Turnage, who’s designed and assembled the book — not to mention creating the beautiful cover.

So what are my contributions to this book? Well, besides writing the introduction, I have two stories:

The Shape of a Legend uses the “Tests, Allies and Enemies” stage, and all those elements make up significant aspects of the story. That’s especially true of “tests”, as the central part of the story is a traditional fairy-tale “three tests” sequence — although not quite done in the traditional way

A young queen must choose between loyalty to her homeland and family and loyalty to her adopted land and the husband she loves. In the end, though, her magical allies show her that her real choice is about who she wants to be.

Wyrmbane uses the “Resurrection” stage. In the classic Hero’s Journey structure, this is normally interpreted metaphorically, but here it’s completely literal. Wyrmbane is a dragonslayer doomed to eternally fight, die and return to life to fight again.

Until, that is, a dragon offers him a way out. Is Wyrmbane willing to abandon his endless task in order to escape his fate?Quest: 22 Stories of the Hero’s Journey will be released over the summer — so watch this space for more information.

You Get Your Sword and I’ll Get My Trowel — Archaeological Fantasy

We’ve always been fascinated by far-off lands, unknown civilisations and lost cities. Ancient legends, from Gilgamesh to Odysseus to St Brendan, told of voyages that discovered lands lying just a little off the map. During the late mediaeval and early modern period, countless books were published purporting to tell of voyages to bizarre and fantastic countries. These were the books Jonathan Swift was satirising in Gulliver’s Travels.

In time, of course, the world shrank. Or, more accurately, the areas of the world we could plausibly fantasise about shrank, as more and more of the earth was explored. But then a new frontier opened up.

During the 19th and early 20th centuries, archaeology really took off. It wasn’t a new discipline1 but this was when it began to evolve from random hunting for treasure or sacred relics into the academic discipline it is today. Discoveries in Mesopotamia, Egypt, Greece, Asia Minor and many other countries fired the imagination of people who longed for unknown worlds. Here they were, emerging from the past.

Tales of Lost Worlds

In this atmosphere, “lost world” fiction blossomed in the later 19th century, led by H Rider Haggard. In novels such as King Solomon’s Mines and She, many of them featuring his iconic character Allan Quartermain, he created a genre of stories where explorers, mainly in Africa, find lost civilisations, sometimes (as in She, for instance) including supernatural elements.

Haggard writes according to the colonial concepts of his time, and the stories today do come over as racist. For their time, though, they were relatively liberal in their portrayal of Africans, compared with the prevailing views, and many of his African characters were portrayed positively.

Many authors followed Haggard in the lost world genre. Perhaps the most notable was Edgar Rice Burroughs, whose Tarzan books frequently involved the discovery of similar hidden civilisations.

Another approach to archaeology in fantasy popular in the earlier part of the 20th century was for stories that revolved around ancient remains that prove to have supernatural powers. An example of this is A. Merritt’s The Ship of Ishtar, in which an archaeologist gets caught up in a battle between two ancient gods. A related approach can be seen in the 1932 film The Mummy, which combined archaeology, Egyptology and magic.

The Return of the Archaeologist

Lost world tales never disappeared, but they became somewhat less fashionable, until 1981, when Spielberg and Lucas introduced the world to Dr Henry Jones junior — better known as Indiana. George Lucas, who wrote the story, based Indy loosely on Allan Quartermain (including the iconic hat), and the films inspired a whole new range of films and games, from Tomb Raider to the new versions of The Mummy.

Most of the characters in these, like Quartermain and the heroes he inspired, are explorers and treasure hunters more than real archaeologists2, but serious archaeology was also becoming extremely popular, at least in the UK. This was largely due to various TV shows, such as Time Team, which showed archaeology in progress and had huge audiences.

Some experts accused these programmes of dumbing down the discipline. Whether or not this was justified, the fact remains that large numbers of people were not only hooked, but also could recognise Samian ware when they saw it and understood the importance of geophysical surveys. They were both educating and entertaining the public.

Nevertheless, mingling fantasy adventures with the methodical processes of true archaeology has proved less successful. The BBC drama series Bonekickers (2008), for instance, attempted this and bombed. In spite of having excellent writers and cast, it proved to be rather dull and unconvincing.

Archaeology in Other Worlds

Lost world stories have also been a staple of secondary world fantasy. This is especially true of sword & sorcery, where endless heroes and heroines have crossed mountains to find forgotten kingdoms or searched dense forest for lost cities, lost temples, lost towers… lost pretty much anything. For the most part, they’re after the treasure that’s been left lying around, but occasionally they also crave (as Henry Jones senior put it) “enlightenment”.

But what about real archaeological fantasy in secondary worlds? After all, Indy and his kind investigate our world’s ancient legends — and other worlds would have their own to uncover.

Back in 2011, when I was getting into the idea of writing “modern” stories in the Traveller’s World, it occurred to me that archaeology would most likely have developed there. And the big advantage I had was that I’d already written about many of its ancient legends.

The story I wrote was The Lone and Level Sands, which was published as a standalone eBook by Musa Publishing — unfortunately, just before the publisher folded, so that it was only briefly available. It involved two students helping their professor excavate a site associated with the ancient city of Kebash, which occupies a position in their mythology roughly equivalent to Atlantis. And, needless to say, they uncover more than they’d bargained for.

It’s taken a while, but I’m currently working on a sequel, provisionally called Secrets of the Black Cape. Here, the same characters, a few years on, are excavating a site associated with events in At An Uncertain Hour — and again, they find more than they expected, this time perhaps with slight shades of She.

The stories certainly have an Indiana Jones vibe, but they’re also both set in the context of properly organised excavations. I’ve no definite plans for further stories — but there are still plenty of legends to investigate, so who knows?

I’m not aware of any other works of secondary world archaeological fantasy, but it seems unlikely that I’m the only person who’s thought of it. I’d love to read other authors’ takes on the genre — but, in any case, I hope my stories will soon be available to fill the gap.

1 It’s been suggested that the first archaeological expedition (that we know of, at least) was St Helena, mother of the Roman emperor Constantine the Great, finding the True Cross and other relics in Jerusalem in the 4th century. This is highly dubious, but certainly similar activities were common and could loosely be described as archaeology.

2 Although Raiders of the Lost Ark does actually show Indy doing some excavating at one point. Archaeology also plays a significant role in two classic Doctor Who stories: The Daemons and Battlefield.

Diversity in Fantasy

This is a heavily rewritten version of a post I wrote for my old blog almost exactly ten years ago. At the time, I felt points needed to be made about diversity in fantasy, but I suppose I tacitly assumed that things would continue getting gradually better, as they had up until that point.

What a difference ten years can make. With diversity and inclusion now under a more concerted attack than at any time for decades, I think it’s vital that we, as creators as worlds that can be as we choose them to be, don’t make the mistakes of the world around us

Yes, prejudice can certainly be a powerful force in our worlds — and perhaps they wouldn’t work if it weren’t. But we get to choose how it’s presented.

Why Is Diversity Important in Fantasy?

Now, discussions advocating diversity in fantasy (and fiction in general) generally talk about the moral and social importance of showing positive diversity. In particular, it’s important to present positive role-models for members of under-represented races, genders and orientations.

All that’s vital, but there are two other reasons why it’s important. Lack of diversity is unrealistic. Lack of diversity is boring.

We read and watch fantasy, after all, for the differences. We love strange worlds, strange peoples, strange creatures, strange customs. And we want the characters to be varied — heroes and villains, fighters and scholars, royalty and simple folk.

Why would we want them all to be the same race, gender and other forms of identity?

So does that mean every story has to have a “diversity quota”? Not at all, and especially not short stories. If you were write a story set in the World War One trenches, for instance, your cast would have to be predominantly male and probably mostly white — though any opportunities for more diversity would be welcome.

There are even situations in secondary worlds where this makes sense. I’ve written stories with all-male casts, but then again I’ve also written stories with all-female casts. When you’re only dealing with two or three people, it has to meet a specific need.

Diversity is best measured over an author’s opus, or even over a widespread trend. It doesn’t mean I’ve failed, after all, if I write one story focusing on white males. The next story might have black females coming to the fore.

Race in Fantasy

Traditionally, fantasy and SF worlds have tended to be populated by a wide variety of exotic races — yet they tend to be depressingly uniform. Elves are all snooty tree-huggers, for instance, dwarves are all gruff axe-wielders, Klingons are all obsessed with their honour… and so on.

In SF, if a human protagonist visits a planet, they’re likely to find an alien race who are all alike and all follow a single culture and religion, wherever they are on the planet.1 And, where a fantasy world is populated by humans, those humans will very often be exclusively European-type in both race and culture.

OK, to be fair, film and TV adaptations are increasingly dealing with this — but usually in a very illogical, haphazard way. Not that I’m criticising “colour-blind” casting, but it doesn’t give a very realistic picture of a genuinely diverse world. That requires races, cultures and religions that have grown up naturally in situ.

Why would the entire population of a world be either alike or just randomly different? There are good reasons why people are different in different parts of our world. We all started off black, in Africa a hundred thousand years ago, and we’ve adapted to the climate and conditions our ancestors settled in. The same would be true of any world populated by humans — and probably by any humanoid species.

That doesn’t mean, though, that they have to slavishly follow what happens in our world. Of course, to a large extent races with lighter skins will tend to live in cooler climates and those with darker skins in the hotter regions, but this doesn’t mean they’ll necessarily have the same cultures as their real-world equivalents.

In my main world, for instance, the predominantly black continent not only had ancient, high-achieving civilisations (as Africa did) but, in the “modern” era, these civilisations were never destroyed or held back by colonialism and slavery. Now, some might say that, in portraying black races who don’t have the legacy of the slave trade and colonial exploitation, I’m belittling that heritage.

My view, however, is the exact opposite. It seems to me that, if I were to portray another, unrelated world whose black races have suffered slavery en masse, I’d be coming perilously close to suggesting that was some kind of natural destiny for black people. Obviously it’s not. In our world, it was something done to Africa as a result of a specific lining up of global factors, and there’s no reason to assume this would happen in a different world.

Gender in Fantasy

Both SF and fantasy were at one time predominantly about men. Not exclusively. William Morris, writing fantasy in the 1890s, tended to create stronger and more vivid female characters. This included The Water of the Wondrous Isles, which focused almost entirely on the heroine, with the “hero” reduced almost entirely to love interest.

Morris was an exception, though, and aside from a few female main characters, such as C.L. Moore’s Jirel of Joiry, for the first two-thirds of the 20th century fantasy was largely the domain of men. Things began to improve a little with the emergence of more female authors in the 60s and 70s, such as Ursula Le Guin, Andre Norton, Tanith Lee and Louise Cooper, but it was a slow process.2

On the face of it, you might think this battle has been won, but here, as in other areas of diversity, we’ve been going backwards for a few years now. That could be seen clearly by the outcry when Doctor Who introduced a female Doctor. Many reasons for this were given by the objectors, but on the whole much of it boiled down to good old misogyny.

Even when female characters do play a significant role in modern fantasy, though, there’s often a tendency to portray them in subservient roles in their society. You might say that this is how the world always has been, and it would be unrealistic to portray things any other way.

To some extent, that’s true, and it would be a reasonable argument if you’re writing about a real historical setting. Although, like so many other things that “everyone knows about history”, the real picture is a lot more complex. But, as with race, a secondary world doesn’t necessarily have to follow the same cultural assumptions as our world. As long as there’s a good internal logic, you can have whatever kind of society you want, including sexual equality. Invoking history is just an excuse.

Other Diversity in Fantasy

Race and gender are both crucial diversity issues, but by no means the only ones. Sexual orientation is a huge factor and, like race and gender, fantasy has made huge strides with this in recent years — but that’s under attack now in society in general.

In my experience, an LGBTQIA+ character is more often than not met with the question “What’s the justification for their orientation?” And, of course, it might seem reasonable to ask that about any facet of any character — but the problem is that it’s a question only reserved for those that are seen as “different”. I don’t recall anyone ever asking “What’s the justification for making this character a straight white male?”

The implication is that you should only have a gay character if you’re dealing explicitly with “gay issues”, just as it’s also implied you should only have a black character if you’re dealing with “racial issues”. Certainly, you may want to use the character for that purpose, but to insist that they’re irrelevant otherwise is to create a ghetto with very high walls.

This is even more the case for other kinds of inclusion. When did you last come across a disabled or neurodiverse character in fantasy? I’m not saying they don’t exist, and there’s certainly more probability of them featuring than a few decades ago — but I’d personally struggle to think of many.

Diversity in the Traveller’s World

The Traveller’s World, in which a large proportion of my stories are set, started out in the 1970s, and back then I was writing about a small group of countries inhabited by European-type populations. While I did include a number of female major characters, and even one or two gay ones, the majority were straight white males.

This has changed as both my perspectives and the world have grown, and the world now comprises seven continents. These have white, black, yellow, red and tan races (plus an isolated race with a green tinge) in a roughly similar distribution as in our world (except for the green race, that is).

I also have a lot more female characters. This is partly a conscious choice, but I’ve also come to realise that, on balance, I actually enjoy writing women more than men. Of my six recurring-character series in the Traveller’s World, three have female protagonists, one a male protagonist, and two a male and female who alternate point of view.

The racial spread isn’t quite as even — of the eight characters, only one is black, two would be middle-eastern in our world, one would be half Chinese, half Native American, while three are white. In terms of sexuality, four are straight, two bisexual, one gay and one asexual. And my latest addition, known as the Maimed Warrior, is disabled.

I have made mistakes in terms of inclusion, though. The one I’m most annoyed with myself about, in hindsight, is in At An Uncertain Hour, which centres around a thousand-year war where each side is led by an immortal. And, although the continent on which the war takes place has a predominantly black population, the two immortals are white.

This isn’t for any obviously “colonial” purposes. The idea for the novel goes back decades, when the issue simply didn’t occur to me. While I don’t believe I’ve been at all belittling to any of the many black characters in the novel, I certainly wouldn’t write it that way now.

I don’t think the issue’s egregious enough to warrant withdrawing a book I’m otherwise proud of, but I do apologise for it. I’ll do better in the future.

The Future of Diversity in Fantasy

As I said at the beginning, ten years ago I assumed diversity, both in fantasy and in the world generally, would be continuing on an upward trajectory, but that’s no longer guaranteed. There’ll no doubt be people who regard this blog as “woke” and “virtue signalling”.3 To those, I’d simply ask: “Are you actually a bigot, or taken in by bigoted rhetoric?”

I suspect there’s going to be a sharp divergence, with one group of fantasy authors and readers (of whom there are still many) asking for and writing more and subtler diversity, while another group slips back into the old prejudices. So there’ll be a choice between boring, monochromatic worlds and stories, and those trying to further explore the whole, amazing range of possibilities in humanity — and beyond.

I know which I’ll be reading and writing.

1 Assuming there is anywhere else on the planet. “A planet”, especially in film or television SF, often seems to consist of nothing but one city, or a small group of villages. In the same way, a fantasy “world” is often only a handful of kingdoms surrounded by terra incognita.

2 Even Le Guin and Norton initially tended to default to male main characters, although they certainly had more gender diversity than most of their male colleagues.

3 As idiotic terms as most of those that allow bigots to believe they have the moral high ground. “Woke” means being awake to what’s important, while as for “virtue signalling” — anyone who doesn’t set a personal example of their moral position is a hypocrite.

My Writing Goals for 2025

It doesn’t seem five minutes since I was posting my goals for 2024, and now it’s time to do the same for 2025. The past twelve months have certainly thrown up some unexpected plot twists on the world stage, but it hasn’t been a bad year for my writing. I didn’t achieve all my goals — but, on the other hand, I achieved some that weren’t planned. So that’s not bad.

What Happened in 2024

Like the previous year, 2024 was to be “the year of the short story”. Progress in 2023 had been painfully slow, since I’d been finding difficulty carving out times when I could get stuck into writing. Towards the end of the year, though, a friend recommended taking the approach of simply making a commitment to write 50 words a day. I’ve largely stuck to that through 2024 (with the variation of 200 words when I’m revising) and found that I’ve invariably far exceeded the target. It’s a great psychological trick to play on yourself.

The first task was to get the unfinished Shadows in the City finished. I did so early in the year, rounding it off at 30,631 words. And that’s just the first draft. Both my own thoughts and invaluable peer critiques have left me realising that it needs a lot of work, and will most likely end up closer to 40,000, near the longer end of the novella scale. I haven’t written anything before in that slot.

After that, my goal was to write five more stories, not counting flash or drabble piece. I got drafts of the first two done before the end of March — The Forbidden Library about recurring characters Kari and Fai, and The Demons of the Past, about a new (hopefully) recurring character, known as the Maimed Warrior.

Then I got sidetracked for a while. Fantasy-Writers.org, the online writers group I help run (and affectionately known as FWO), decided to get together a second anthology — only ten years after the first. We chose for a theme the stages of the classic Hero’s Journey, so I ended up writing two unplanned stories for it — The Shape of a Legend and Wyrmbane. I’ll be blogging more about this over the next few months.

Back to plan, and I wrote a new story about my young thief Loshi, Smoke and Mirrors, and then I returned, after a very long gap, to my comic fantasy series about Sam Nemesis, private investigator to gods, heroes and monsters. I wrote the first three in 2011 and 2012, and two were quickly published, but I hadn’t been back to it. I wrote two new ones — The Case of the Missing Eye, about Odysseus and the Cyclops, and The Case of the Forty-Two Pieces, which takes on the Egyptian myth of Isis and Osiris — Sam’s first venture outside Greek mythology.

That was going to be all, but I added another unplanned story. Secrets of the Black Cape is a sequel to my novella The Lone and Level Sands, which was published by Musa in 2013, though now out of print. This is archaeological fantasy, in the Indiana Jones tradition but set in a secondary world. It was planned on being around 10,000 words but ended up over 17,000 — and the second draft will almost certainly be much longer.

There were other bits and pieces. I wrote six flash or drabble length stories, as well as expanding a very short flash piece into a longer story. This was The Other Stars, one of my rare pieces of pure SF. I also came across a story called The Omniscient which I wrote in 2011 and never did anything with. It’s an extremely weird story (maybe I didn’t know what to make of it) but I liked it and revised it into a usable shape.

The aim was to write all the first drafts in the first half of the year and then move onto revision — but that didn’t quite happen. I got both the anthology stories completely revised, but otherwise it was the end of September by the time I had all the first drafts done and could start revising.

By the time the year ended, I still had the final polishes to be done on The Forbidden Library and Smoke and Mirrors, while I’ve done nothing yet on The Tower of Zeka-Zomi (left over from 2023), Secrets of the Black Cape and Shadows in the City. And I certainly haven’t done anything about revising the current novel yet, as I’d hoped.

I was also targeting 52 submissions (I made 64), 52 critiques on Fantasy-Writers.org (I did 69) and post 12 blogs (I did 11). As far as acceptances are concerned, not counting the anthology I’ve had three drabbles and two flashes published, as well as one longer story — Gerda and the Darkness in a Harvey Duckman Presents anthology. But still no book. The publisher that has Echoes of Ancient Magic in its queue has been having problems, and I’m not sure it’s actually going to happen.

Goals for 2025

My 2025 goals are straightforward enough. The earlier months of the year will be devoted to getting the remaining stories submission ready. That’s started well, with The Forbidden Library already done, but the three last stories (The Tower of Zeka-Zomi, Secrets of the Black Cape and Shadows in the City) are likely to be the most time consuming, and I don’t anticipate those being finished till late spring or summer.

Then, finally, I’ll be back to the novel. It currently has the working title The Empire of Nandesh, but I’m considering calling it Sharper Than a Serpent’s Tongue. The phrase is from King Lear: “How sharper than a serpent’s tooth it is/To have a thankless child.” This is because the novel focuses on a series of dysfunctional parent-child relationships — some literally a parent and child, some an analogous relationship.

The novel is a sequel to At An Uncertain Hour, but I think it could be understood reasonably well without having read that. The main action (though there are plenty of scenes at earlier times) is set over eight hundred years later — and, just to keep me on my toes, it features four separate first-person narrators.

Based on both the feedback from colleagues on FWO and my own feelings, the second draft is going to need some major surgery, so I’m not counting on being done before the end of the year. If I am — well, I’ll cross that bridge when I come to it (which is, of course, the only time you can cross a bridge).

I’ll be carrying on with the aim of writing at least 50 words or revising at least 200 words every day, and I’ll also be targeting 52 submissions, 52 critiques on FWO and 12 blogs — ideally nicely spaced out at one a month, but maybe that’s too much to ask. And I’ll redouble my efforts to get a book published during the year.

And, speaking of books published, there’s also going to be the publication of the FWO anthology. Although I’m not primarily responsible for that, there’ll no doubt be a lot I can do both to help make it happen and to work on publicising it. So you’ll see more about it here — watch this space.

And I’ll see you in January 2026, to find out how I got on with it all.

First-Snow Feast — A Story for Christmas

Cautiously, Icerag the snowman opened one coal-eye and peered through the steadily falling snow. It was nearly dark, apart from the pools of streetlight and the glow from the houses of the Warms.

How had they made him this time? Warms could be cruel, and snowmen were at the mercy of their whims. One winter, they’d given him a courgette, instead of a carrot, as his nose, and everyone had laughed at him.

It must be nearly time for the First-Snow Feast, marking the start of the brief snowman year, a holiday to celebrate waking again for another winter. They always gathered at Crystal’s, so, with a glance to check he was unobserved, Icerag moved off. The journey was tiring, but not long. Crystal was only a few gardens over.

She looked radiant as always, at the centre of their group. The Warms who made her, year after year, paid a lot of attention to detail, and an icy shiver of desire passed through Icerag at the sight of her perfectly spaced eyes, the sweet little carrot of a nose and the delicious paunch of her belly. She was perfect, yet again.

Icerag experienced that strange melting feeling Crystal always gave him. To distract himself, he asked, “Everyone here?”

The mood immediately grew sombre. “No Snowflake again,” said Crystal.

No-one commented, but Icerag knew they were all thinking the same. Snowflake had new Warms, who hadn’t made him last year. It was every snowman’s dread.

“Never mind,” said Crystal determinedly. “The feast’s ready. We have a plump, succulent one this year. I don’t think it’s been missed yet.”

All the snowmen looked down at where a tiny Warm’s head poked out of the snow, its body buried deep enough to restrict movement. Its absurd eyes were darting all over the place, instead of staying still, but the snow packed into its mouth was stopping it from making any of their strange sounds.

“Perfect,” said Icerag. “Let’s eat.”

And half a dozen snowmen gathered around to begin devouring the little Warm. It was going to be a splendid feast.

Gerda and the Darkness Published in Death +70

My story Gerda and the Darkness was recently published in Death +70, the rather curiously titled anthology from the equally curiously titled imprint Harvey Duckman Presents. This is a collection of eighteen stories by a variety of authors, whose theme is described as “Tantalising Tales from Beyond the Apocalypse”.

The publisher describes it as “a disturbingly dark collection of post-apocalyptic and dystopian fiction, rich in zombies and plague, wasteland raiders and alien invaders, lost tech and ancient lore, nuclear Armageddon, the end of the world and beyond…”

Needless to say, I’m delighted to be in the anthology, especially as this is a story I’ve been trying to get published for some time. I wrote it ten years ago and was delighted and proud of it — but it was only after racking up nineteen rejections that Harvey Duckman finally accepted it.

Realistically, I have a good idea why markets may not have been falling over themselves to publish this story. Rather than being written in the immersive style popular today (and my more common approach to fiction), Gerda and the Darkness is more like a folk tale with a more traditional storytelling approach.

I’m realistic enough to understand this wasn’t my most saleable story —though more so than my still-unsold second person, future-tense piece (another one I still believe in). So It’s wonderful that Harvey Duckman seem to have seen in it what I always saw.

Nevertheless, it’s a little surprising that they saw it as fitting into this particular anthology. Although there is a hint of the dystopian, it’s definitely an outlier in the collection.

I don’t remember clearly what motivated me to write it, but one inspiration was probably the opening lines of Paul Simon’s song The Sound of Silence1: “Hello darkness, my old friend, I’ve come to talk with you again.” Allegedly (although I’ve no idea if this is true) it was a regular saying of a blind friend of Simon’s musical partner Art Garfunkel.

The story concerns Gerda, a young woman who lives in a traditional-style Scandinavian village on the hills above a fjord. No specific location is ever given, and I tend to think of it as a parallel version, rather than a real-world Scandinavia.

As a child who’s a bit of a loner, Gerda meets and befriends an entity called Darkness. Far from being scary or menacing, the Darkness becomes a good friend, telling Gerda endless stories, including some about the ultimate dark beyond any stars, which she loves.

When Gerda is a young woman, the community is threatened by raiders — but raiders like none they’ve heard of before. These come from a highly industrialised and urbanised society, with hints that it’s an expansionist dictatorship, who intend to exploit the land for its mineral wealth. And the people are simply in the way.

Without giving away any spoilers, it’s Gerda and the Darkness who save the day, and Gerda is rewarded with a somewhat twisted (but genuine) heart’s desire.

Gerda and the Darkness, along with the other seventeen stories, is available from Amazon as a Kindle, a paperback or a hardback. You can find it on Amazon.co.uk or Amazon.com — or just tweak the URL to fit your country’s version of Amazon.

I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it

1 The title has been variously given as The Sound of Silence and The Sounds of Silence. I believe the singular version was Simon’s title of choice.

Review of A Voyage to Arcturus by David Lindsay

Back in the 1970s, I read a strange, captivating novel called A Voyage to Arcturus. I recently reread it, and it seemed appropriate to give my thoughts on a book that few readers nowadays seem aware of, even though it’s been immensely influential.

The title would lead to the assumption that this is SF — and it is, in a way, but only to the same extent as C.S. Lewis’s space trilogy. And, in fact, Lewis was strongly influenced by it. In reality, this is a glorious but bewildering mixture of SF, S&S, religious allegory, surrealism and philosophical tract.

David Lindsay wrote the book in 1920, his first novel at the age of 44.1 Like a great many people at the time, he’d been traumatised and disillusioned by four years of war, in which he’d served in the army. His disillusion, indeed, seems a close parallel to Hitler’s, but Lindsay used his as a creative force, rather than a destructive one.

The novel begins in familiar territory, with a contemporary (i.e. 1920) scene in London describing a high-society séance.2 We’re introduced in a fair amount of detail to a range of characters who disappear after the first chapter, before two outsiders arrive — a large man called Maskull, and a smaller man called Nightspore.

After the séance goes wrong, it’s gate-crashed by a strange, uncouth man called Krag, who takes Maskull and Nightspore away and tell them they must journey to Arcturus. This is achieved from a remote Scottish observatory, in a capsule powered by rays from Arcturus that seek to return there.

Having passed out on the way, Maskull wakes to find himself alone of the planet Tormance, which orbits Arcturus, with no trace of his two companions. It’s a strange world. There are two suns — a normal, though larger and hotter, one called Branchspell, and a mysterious blue sun called Allpain, which can only be seen from the far north.

Tormance has many unique features, including two extra primary colours, called ulfire and jale, entirely unlike any colour on Earth. These appear, along with blue, to form the spectrum of Allpain, while Branchspell’s spectrum is the normal one.3

The landscapes of the planet are varied and bizarre, as are the flora and fauna. The water is, in many places, dense enough to walk on, while another type of water is a complete substitute for food. Mountains are piled up in impossible configurations, plants often walk about, while in one region Maskull witnesses endless new lifeforms coming into being as he watches.

When he starts to meet the inhabitants of Tormance, they’re equally strange. Most have extra organs, ranging in different regions from the poign, which enables understanding and empathy, to the sorb, by which one person can control another’s will. And one companion Maskull meets is of a third sex — not a mingling of male and female, but something as entirely separate as the colours. Lindsay coins the pronouns ae, aer and aerself to refer to this person.

Maskull travels through various lands on Tormance. This is partly from curiosity and partly a desire to see the blue sun Allpain in the far north, but also in search of a mysterious figure called Surtur. This person may or may not be the god of Tormance, otherwise called Crystalman or Shaping. Different Tormance cultures have a variety of views about this.

Maskull’s journey — meeting a range of philosophies, from ultimate love and altruism to a compulsion for dominating others, and being strongly influenced by each as he goes — has superficial similarities to Bunyan’s The Pilgrim’s Progress, but this is no comfortable religious allegory. Where Bunyan clearly labels the significance of his places and people, Tormance remains a puzzle to be struggled with.

From strong attraction at the beginning to a philosophy of non-violence, Maskull is quickly seduced away. His trail is eventually littered with bodies — some he’s killed himself, others he’s failed to protect. He also has relationships with a number of women — none of whom survive the encounter.

Finally, now weary of life, he meets up again with Krag, who he’s heard described as Tormance’s Devil, along with an affable man who proves to be Crystalman. Maskull eventually comes to see Crystalman, the god of pleasure and the material world, as a corrupter who turns the spark of life into grossness, while Krag constantly challenges the desire for pleasure.

As Maskull dies, Nightspore re-emerges, and we’re left with the assumption that he’s actually Maskull’s soul. It’s Nightspore who’ll go on, helping Krag in his fight.

A Voyage to Arcturus is a captivating book, but not an easy one. For one thing, Lindsay’s postwar vision is incredibly bleak — the world is corrupt and evil, as is the God worshipped in it, and only by holding onto the tiny uncorrupted spark of life within can anyone have a hope in the struggle of life.

The meaning we’re supposed to take from it is also difficult to define. This is no obvious allegory, and we have to pick through the many philosophies put before us if we hope to get an inkling of its meaning. As Tolkien, who loved the book, said, “no one could read it merely as a thriller and without interest in philosophy, religion and morals”.

The novel has its faults, too. The prose is often clunky, though the lushness of the descriptions largely compensates for that, and the characters are curiously undeveloped. Even Maskull — although we have occasional vague references to dissatisfaction with his life on Earth, we’re told nothing whatsoever about that life. Not even how he knows Nightspore.

The book’s attitude to women isn’t entirely in line with modern standards, as might be expected from something more than a hundred years old, although it’s far better than some from the period. In fact, it isn’t easy to pick out the author’s views from those of the many philosophies Maskull encounters. Some of these are deeply misogynistic, but on the other hand most of the female characters seem to have more agency than their male counterparts.

In spite of its faults, A Voyage to Arcturus is a compelling book that won’t easily let go of you once you’ve read it. Although a commercial failure at the time (fewer than 600 copies were sold of the first press run), many authors have admired and been influenced by it.

Besides Tolkien, C.S. Lewis described it as “shattering, intolerable, and irresistible” and acknowledged it as a major influence on several of his own works.4 Michael Moorcock considered that “Few English novels have been as eccentric or, ultimately, as influential”, while Philip Pullman and Clive Barker have both praised it.

A Voyage to Arcturus is anything but light reading, and some readers will certainly find it too much. If you love philosophical conundrums along with the action, though, I’d certainly recommend following Maskull across the landscapes of Tormance.

1 The introduction to the edition I have (Pan/Ballantine, 1972) erroneously describes Lindsay as a “young forgotten writer” who “died young”. In fact, he died in 1945, aged 69 — not old, maybe, but not particularly young.

2 It’s quite an unusual séance, and I suspect Lindsay didn’t actually know what went on at séances, just inventing it to serve his purpose.

3 Lindsay does make an error with the “normal” spectrum, describing it as red, yellow and blue, even though he’s talking about the light of Branchspell.

4 Most notably his “space trilogy” (Out of the Silent Planet, Perelandra and That Hideous Strength), but also The Screwtape Letters.

A Fantasy World That’s All Grown Up

There’s a very clear traditional idea of what a fantasy world is supposed to be like. It has warriors riding horses and wielding swords and axes. It doesn’t have them travelling on planes and operating computers. It just doesn’t.

But why not? After all, our world has had all that and much, much more, at various times and locations. So why does a secondary world have to be frozen like a fly in amber? Sooner or later, all worlds have to grow up.

The Mediaeval World That Fantasy Isn’t

Perhaps the most widespread fallacy about fantasy secondary worlds is that they’re all mediaeval — by which people normally mean simply that they have horses and swords. In fact, “mediaeval” is a very specific range of cultures, relating to Western Europe between 732 and 1453 AD.1

Even so, customs and norms varied considerably between those dates and in different parts of Europe, but two crucial features can be picked out that define the era. One was the feudal system. The other was the unique position of the Church.

There are fantasy novels set in a genuinely mediaeval-style culture, of course. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series is perhaps the most obvious, as well as William Morris’s works like The Well at the World’s End. However, they’re very much in the minority.

Consider the various societies portrayed in Lord of the Rings, for instance. The Shire is essentially rural 19th century England without gunpowder (apart from fireworks); the Dwarves are Vikings; Rohan is very early Anglo-Saxon, as portrayed in Beowulf; and Gondor is perhaps more like ancient Babylon than anything. Then there are other societies, such as the Elven kingdoms and Mordor, that have no particular historical model.

In fact, a more typical kind of fantasy world (especially when it comes to sword & sorcery) most closely resembles the world of Classical mythology. A world where rootless heroes wander between tiny kingdoms whose constitutional arrangements are sketchy, to say the least, and whose religions mostly seem to involve sacrificing beautiful virgins. For all its faults, the mediaeval Church tended not to do that.2

Fantasy in the Modern World

There’s always been fantasy set in our own contemporary world, of course, but secondary world fantasy has tended to be, if not mediaeval, certainly pre-gunpowder. There have been slight exceptions. In Andre Norton’s Witch World series, for instance, she goes as far as to give Witch World warriors dart guns, but there’s also futuristic tech — although it’s been brought in from outside their world.

More recently, though, some fantasy authors have been experimenting with different kinds of settings. That’s often been to do with a less Eurocentric focus, but some settings have been post-gunpowder, or even societies with similarities to the modern world.

The New Weird movement, whose best-known exponent is China Miélville, mixes genres. It typically employs invented urban fantasy settings, often with modern or steampunk overtones, but featuring a wide range of fantasy races and themes. In Miélville’s world of Bas-Lag, for instance (as featured in Perdido Street Station and other novels) dozens of strange and wonderful types of sentient beings coexist with railways and other Victorian-level technology.

One of my favourite examples of this movement is Mary Gentle’s Rats & Gargoyles. This is set in a vast city (we’re told it spreads over several time zones) which initially seems very much like a classic fantasy city, apart from being ruled by human-sized rats. As the story unfolds, though, we gradually realises that it actually possesses a wide range of modern technology.

Letting Worlds Grow Up

When I started writing stories in what was to become the Traveller’s World, it was very much a classic fantasy world. Right at the beginning, in fact, I was referring to characters as knights, and there was more than a hint of Arthurian legend about it, although this quickly morphed into something closer to classical Greece.

Quite early, I found my way to using different parts of the world and widely separated time periods, but they were all essentially pre-tech. I did allow a little progress, though at my own preferred rate (they had the printing press before gunpowder, for instance), but essentially it remained an “ancient” world.

Then, about twenty years ago, I began to reconsider. It occurred to me that, logically, at some point much later than anything I’d yet written, this world too would “grow up”. I began to wonder what this “modern” world would make of the major legends of its past, such as the Traveller.

The first fruit of this line of thinking was a story called Present Historic, in which a “modern” diplomat is inspired to pursue international cooperation by legends of the Traveller — which now appear as films and comic books. This idea fascinated me. Although I continued (and still continue) to write plenty of stories in “classic” settings, I began exploring this new, grown-up Traveller’s World.

Not all the settings are entirely modern. One is what I call “flintlock & sorcery” (a kind of fantasy equivalent of The Three Musketeers), while others are set in a gaslight era. Many, though, are set in a period that features equivalents of smartphones and PCs — and a few are even slightly in advance of our current level of progress.3

I’d already established, in the classic fantasy, that the Traveller’s World isn’t so very different from ours. It doesn’t have six moons, or bizarre sentient beings living side by side with humans (well, not many, at least), and I extended this into the modern era. Overall, the societies and their technologies have developed in ways similar to ours — though with certain differences. Cars are all electric, for instance, planes are VTOL, and you “dial up the vidscreen”, rather than turn on the TV. Broadly, though, it’s much the same.

Just like much contemporary fantasy set in our own world (especially paranormal fantasy) the predominant theme in these stories is the effect of the supernatural traditions of the past on a rational, sophisticated society. Here, it can be anything from people trying to revive worship of the Demon Queen or the Great One (the global power of evil) to finding remnants of ancient, paranormal races.

How Far Can a Secondary World Go?

So I have stories set in various iron age societies of the Traveller’s World (the comfort zone for fantasy) and also stories set in its “early modern” and “modern” eras. But are there are other periods that would work? How far can a secondary world go?

Well, possibilities do exist. I have a couple of stories set in the bronze age, for example — but there are limits. If I wanted to write stories about palaeolithic hunter-gatherers, for instance, what would distinguish it from a story set in that era of our world?

We know nothing really of the cultures or languages or beliefs from that far back, and the characters wouldn’t have names for the countries or areas they live in. Unless the secondary world had something quite distinct (those six moons, for instance), there’d be no difference between a story set in the forests of northern Europe and one set in the great Kimdyran Forest.4

Curiously, the same applies if you go too far beyond a “contemporary” setting. There’s certainly room to get a little futuristic, but when the people of the Traveller’s World start boldly going where no man has gone before, the universe they explore could just as well be the universe our descendants might explore.

Some heritage elements could be brought in, of course. Some of the cities back home might be the same, and a pioneering starship could be named Searcher, after the Traveller’s vessel. But these would be largely cosmetic elements. There’d be little true reason for the story being set in a secondary world.

So, it seems, the useful life of a secondary world is from the end of the stone age to the beginning of the interstellar age. Which leaves plenty of room to explore, whether your tastes run to sword & sorcery or to urban fantasy. Or both.

So have fun.

1 There are various reasons for singling out the Battle of Tours in 732 as the beginning of the Middle Ages, but the principal one was that it began the supremacy of the knight as a fighting force, with the feudal system that came along with it. The fall of Constantinople to the Ottomans in 1453 was significant in itself, but it also marked the point where all the major features of the early modern era were under way.

2 Unless you count burning heretics at the stake, of course.

3 An example of this is a story called Tattered Wings, in which even a fairly low-income family lives in a house with voice-activated lights and other systems.

4 I actually do have a palaeolithic story set in the Traveller’s World — but only because I say so. It could just as well be set in our prehistory.

The Aryan Fallacy

Note: This is an updated version of a post on my old blog from 2015. Recent events suggest that it may need saying again.


In 1938, J.R.R. Tolkien received a letter from a German publisher who proposed to publish a translation of The Hobbit. According to the laws under the Nazi government, they requested him to confirm that he was “of Aryan origin”.

Tolkien was livid. He made his opinion clear in a related letter to his British publisher, where he said, “I have many Jewish friends, and should regret giving any colour to the notion that I subscribed to the wholly pernicious and unscientific race-doctrine.”1

In his reply to the German publisher, he feigns innocence at first. “I regret that I am not clear as to what you intend by arisch. I am not of Aryan extraction: that is Indo-iranian; as far as I am aware none of my ancestors spoke Hindustani, Persian, Gypsy, or any related dialects.”2

Tolkien had no truck at all with the Aryan Fallacy, but many of his contemporaries embraced it enthusiastically, including several other fantasy writers active at a similar time — very notably Robert E. Howard. So how did it come about?

The Original Aryans

The word Aryan (or more strictly Arya) correctly refers to a group of nomadic tribes that moved into northern India about three to three-and-a-half thousand years ago. In fact, there’s evidence that it didn’t originally refer to an ethnic group at all, but to a culture — and, more specifically, to a status within this culture. Many of the kings defining themselves as “Arya” appear to have been indigenous rulers who’d adopted the ways of the newcomers. This parallels the way that diverse peoples from all over the Roman Empire became “Romans” by learning Latin, adopting Roman names and following Roman customs.

The term Aryan is also used for the linguistic family descended from Sanskrit, deriving ultimately from the language(s) spoken by these tribes and their converts. Lastly, and with extreme caution, it can be applied to the people who speak these modern languages (most of the languages of Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, northern and central India, and the majority language of Sri Lanka). As long as it’s understood that this in no way represents a racial identity.

The family, as Tolkien indicated, also includes Romani (“Gypsy”), its original speakers having migrated from north-west India. Ironically, in Hitler’s time (i.e. before the mass migrations from the sub-continent after World War Two) the only substantial ethnic group in Europe who could legitimately call themselves Aryan were the Romani — who were persecuted by the Nazis.

The most obviously related group of languages is the Iranian family, together forming the Indo-Iranian group (Iran derives from the same root as Aryan). Today, the Iranian group covers most languages of Iran and Afghanistan, together with Kurdish, but in earlier historical periods Iranian-speaking nomads lived on the steppes north of the Black and Caspian Seas: Scythians, Sarmatians, Alans etc.

The Origins of the Fallacy

In the late 18th century, linguists began to recognise a clear relationship between the earliest forms of Sanskrit, Greek and Latin, and postulated that they might all have derived from a common source. With this leverage to build on, the Germanic, Celtic, Slavonic and other language groups were added to the growing super-family, nowadays known as Indo-European. An extinct family of Indo-European languages, Tocharian, was even spoken in north-west China during the Han era.

In the 19th century, it was proposed that the whole family should be called Aryan, in the erroneous belief that this was the earliest name of a people speaking an Indo-European language3 and therefore the most likely to be the original.

Though mistaken, this was originally innocuous, but a tide of racial supremacism gradually saw the label become more and more equated with the “German Race”. The concept was that the “original Aryans” had been white, blond and blue eyed, but had subsequently mixed with “lesser” races. In fact, the reality is more likely to be the opposite — the lighter colouring evolved from living in a colder climate.

Max Müller, one of the originators of the original proposition, was later scathing about colleagues who confused linguistic and racial characteristics, suggesting that “Aryan race, Aryan blood, Aryan eyes and hair” were as absurd as “a dolichocephalic dictionary or a brachycephalic grammar”.4

The tide was against him, though, and the concept of the Aryan Master Race became more and more widespread, eventually finding its lunatic home in the warped mind of Adolf Hitler. In fact, there have been suggestions that the characteristic differences between the Germanic languages (including English) and all other Indo-European languages may have been the result of an unrelated people abandoning their own language and taking up a broken form of Indo-European. In which case, the Germans have even less right to the name Aryan than most other Indo-European speakers.

The Indo-European Language Family

The clear pattern of divergence among the languages through various periods has always suggested that it should be possible to trace them all back to a time when a single language, from which they are all descended, was spoken by a community in a relatively small area. The favourite explanation nowadays is the steppes of south-eastern Europe somewhere between 4500 and 2500 BC, but other propositions have ranged from the eccentric (such as the North Pole) to the vaguely plausible (such as Anatolia or the north-western European plains).

It shouldn’t be assumed, though, that these original Indo-Europeans represented a race, or even a “people” as we’d understand it. Archaeological evidence suggests that the communities who probably spoke Indo-European were actually made up of several distinct groups — a people who’d come down from the north, another who’d come up from the Mediterranean, and possibly others from Central Asia or the Caucasus — who can all be seen from their remains to have been very different physical types.

Nor are they likely to have had much in common, including political or tribal structures, except the language which allowed ideas and customs to spread. They constituted a culture area, but no more.

In terms of the later spread of Indo-European, too, we can’t assume any racial connection. It’s not unusual for peoples to adopt the language of either the dominant or the “cool” culture, and this often means communities speaking a language aren’t racially connected with the those who spoke the language’s distant ancestor. If we didn’t accept this, we’d have a hard time trying to explain how an English-speaking African American could have derived from the language’s source in north-western Europe.

The subsequent evolution of the languages is likewise anything but straightforward. Linguists use the family tree model (e.g. Latin is the “parent” of French, Spanish, Italian etc.) and this is useful, but the influence of other, often unrelated languages is important too. This can be down to extensive borrowing of vocabulary for social or political reasons, such as how English, fundamentally a Western Germanic language, has a vocabulary heavily derived from Latin.5 It can also be explained, though, by the wave theory of language change.

The wave theory is a model which suggests that specific changes, whether a sound-change such as a final t changing to s or a grammatical change such as the development of grammatical gender, spreads from an epicentre and affects both related and unrelated languages. The next major change will have a different epicentre, and/or the speakers will have moved, so it won’t be the same set of languages affected.

Ultimately, this will create a patchwork, in which it can be difficult to reconcile a language’s position on its family tree with apparent similarities to more distantly related (or unrelated) ones. It’s inconvenient, but we’re talking about human behaviour. What do you expect?

Tracing the Story Further Back

So where did the original Indo-European language come from? If it was being spoken a mere five or six thousand years ago, it obviously can’t have sprung from nowhere. The reason it’s recognised as the “original” is that it marks the latest point that all Indo-European languages can be traced back to, but its history must have gone back a long way up an unknown family tree.

Various propositions have been made as to what Indo-European might ultimately be related to, the most widespread being a super-family known as Nostratic. At its most ambitious, this hypothesis includes Uralic, Altaic, Kartvelian, Afroasiatic, Elamo-Dravidian and Eskimo-Aleut, along with a few others, though some more cautious proponents restrict it to the first three plus Indo-European.6

There’s very little evidence for hypotheses such as this, and what has been put forward is strongly disputed. The problem is that it becomes progressively harder to be sure of similarities between languages the further back the proposed connection is. It’s probable that some, at least, of these language groups actually are linked, but nothing’s likely to ever go beyond speculation.

To speculate, though, how far might this process actually reach? Recent evidence suggests an origin for language considerably further back than was believed even a decade or two ago, certainly back to when our ancestors were living in a fairly small area of Africa.7 Maybe the invention of human language really was a single event, and we’re all speaking variants of the same language. Just as all humans have the same origin.

The Aryan Fallacy should have died in the bunker with the Führer, but unfortunately bigots aren’t famous for their intellectual rigour, and there are still white supremacist morons who use it as a keystone for their disgusting creeds.

So take a leaf out of Tolkien’s book. Next time a white supremacist proudly claims to be Aryan, point out that they’re actually claiming to be Indian. Or even Iranian. You won’t change their views, but see how they like it.

1 The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, ed. Humphrey Carpenter, 1981, p.37

2 Ibid. p.37

3 To be fair, this was a reasonable belief at the time, but earlier examples have been found since then, including the Hittites, who dominated Anatolia during the later Bronze Age.

4 Quoted in In Search of the Indo-Europeans, J.P. Mallory, 1989, p.269

5 That the roots of English are Germanic can be illustrated by taking a passage of average English and identifying where each word came from. It’s likely that more would be Latin-derived than Germanic-derived; but if you were to redo the exercise counting each word each time it’s used, you’d find the count overwhelmingly Germanic. This is because the most common, infrastructure words (the, and, to, for and the like) are direct descendants of the words that came over with the Anglo-Saxons.

6 Uralic includes languages like Finnish and Hungarian; Altaic includes the Turkic languages, Mongolian, probably Korean and possibly Japanese; Kartvelian is a small group whose main member is Georgian; Afroasiatic is a huge group, ranging from Hebrew and Arabic to Hausa, the main language of northern Nigeria, and taking in ancient Egyptian along the way; Dravidian was the main language group in India before the coming of the Aryans, and is still dominant in the south; Eskimo-Aleut — yes, I know Eskimo is non gratis, but there’s actually no other word for the whole linguistic group, the Inuit actually being just the largest ethnic group.

7 Remains have indicated that Neanderthals shared the same deformity of the larynx that allows us to manipulate complex sounds, suggesting that the mutation took place at least 150,000 years ago, probably earlier. On the “use it or lose it” principle of evolution, it’s difficult to interpret this any way other than our ancestors already using language from that point.